Why ministry leaders need more than another strategy.
I was talking with a young adult ministry leader in Colorado this week about building a coaching community for pastors and leaders across the Front Range.
We spent some time discussing the challenges young adult leaders face. Building teams. Developing volunteers. Navigating conversations with senior pastors. Creating meaningful discipleship opportunities. And figuring out what to do when the ministry you inherited isn't necessarily the ministry you want to build.
Somewhere in the conversation, I was reminded of something I wrote back in March of 2020:
People are looking for a shepherd's staff, not a CEO's graph.
Six years later, I think that statement matters just as much, if not more.
Ministry isn't simply a problem to solve.
One of the challenges I see in ministry is our tendency to approach every obstacle as an organizational problem.
Attendance is declining? Change the programming.
Volunteers are disengaged? Recruit more people.
Young adults aren't connecting? Launch another gathering.
And sometimes those are exactly the right things to do. But sometimes we're trying to solve pastoral problems with organizational solutions.
And those aren't always the same thing.
A spreadsheet can tell you how many people attended your gathering. It can't tell you whether those people are becoming more like Jesus.
A leadership chart can show you who is responsible for what. It can't always tell you whether your leaders are healthy, encouraged, or spiritually growing.
A calendar can tell you what your ministry is doing. It can't tell you whether those activities are actually forming people into the people they need to be.
We can become remarkably effective at organizing ministry without becoming particularly effective at shepherding people.
Strategy matters. But people matter more.
And I'm grateful for it.
I’ve learned how to develop ministry plans, communicate goals, manage resources, and build teams around a shared direction.
Those things matter. In fact, I think many young adult leaders would benefit tremendously from developing those skills.
But strategy was never supposed to replace shepherding. It was supposed to support it.
Ephesians 4 reminds us that the work of ministry leadership is to equip God's people for works of service so that the body of Christ might be built up toward maturity.
The goal isn't simply a more efficient ministry. The goal is a more mature people.
And that requires more than systems and strategies. It requires presence, patience, encouragement, correction, and care.
Good coaching should come from the ground, not the tower.
Something else came up during our conversation.
I mentioned that I believe the best ministry coaching comes from people who remain connected to the realities of local church ministry.
Real people. Real problems. Real stories.
It's so easy to sit outside the daily challenges of ministry and develop impressive theories about what churches should be doing. It's entirely another thing to walk alongside leaders who are trying to disciple a difficult person, navigate an unhealthy team dynamic, or communicate a ministry need to a senior pastor who has seventeen other things demanding their attention.
Good coaching shouldn't simply tell leaders what they should do. It should help them understand what they're facing, identify what matters most, and determine a faithful next step.
Sometimes that means developing a better strategy.
Sometimes it means having a difficult conversation.
Sometimes it means stopping something that isn't producing the fruit you hoped it would.
And sometimes it means reminding a tired leader that they're not called to carry the entire weight of their ministry alone.
Build people who gather, not gatherings of people.
This is one of the convictions that continues to shape how I think about young adult ministry.
It's remarkably easy to become consumed with building gatherings. Better environments. Better teaching. Better programming. Better attendance. But what if we measured ministry health by the people we're becoming rather than simply the gatherings we're producing?
Are people growing in their love for Jesus?
Are they developing meaningful relationships?
Are they learning to serve others?
Are they becoming equipped to lead?
Are they taking responsibility for their own spiritual formation?
These are harder things to measure. But they're worth paying attention to.
Because ultimately, the success of our ministry isn't found in how impressive our gatherings become, It's found in the people being formed through them.
A question for ministry leaders.
As you think about the ministry you're leading, consider this:
Are you spending more time managing the ministry you've built or shepherding the people God has entrusted to you?
It's not an either-or question.
Healthy ministries need both leadership and care. Strategy and presence. Organization and discipleship. However, we should also be careful not to confuse the tools we use to lead with the purpose for which we're leading.
At the end of the day, people aren't simply looking for another organizational strategy. They're looking for someone who can help them follow Jesus faithfully.
They need a shepherd's staff, not just a CEO's graph.
If you're leading a young adult, college, or student ministry and wondering where your ministry is healthy or where it needs attention, I've created a free Ministry Health Assessment to help you identify your strengths, challenges, and next steps.